A few months ago, my book club read this book. Now, with the Peacock series out there, I thought I’d share my thoughts on the book as I contemplate whether or not to watch the show, which doesn’t have the greatest rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
My first thought on the book is it’s too long. There is just too much. The print length comes in at 480 pages, which does not seem like a lot, until you are reading it. The audio version is 18 hours and 3 minutes. The average audiobook length is 10 hours. That’s nearly double. I read the first 70% and listened to the last 30% (approximately). I eventually pumped the speed of the audio up to 1.75%. Even so, I kept asking myself, “when is this going to be over?”
The book switches back and forth in time between two fairly close time periods and includes memories/flashbacks to earlier days in both. It also switches the third person pov character. The first switch is signaled at the beginning of the chapter; the second is not. While I initially liked the switching back and forth, it eventually became tiresome. This is another case of too much. For example, there are too many times when we hear of the same incident from multiple points of view. While that could be really interesting, in many cases here the povs are not different enought warrant full retellings. Yes, okay, we get the idea that these family members were all affected in some way by the events of the family’s life, but well, isn’t that life? And, the detailed retellings from each member of the family don’t feel significant enough to warrant the time/space in the book, except that they lead to the next Too Much.
There are just too many coincidences in this book. SPOILER ALERT: STOP READING HERE AND JUMP AHEAD IF YOU HAVEN’T READ THE BOOK. There is just ONE day that Joy breaks down in grief over the death of her mother which happens to be the same day that Logan loses to Troy for the first time and throws his racket and is the same day Brooke catches a kid going through her bookbag and the same day Amy has the strength to stand up for herself and say no to the kid asking her to make her a sandwich. It’s just too much. Oh, and let’s not forget that that day just happens to be the ONE day that kid is at the tennis school.
SPOILER OVER, YOU CAN START READING AGAIN. I will say this in praise of the book, the characterization is very good. Each person’s strengths and insecurities are so believably drawn and the interaction among the family members and between them and outsiders are incredibly realistic. It is easy to see how each develops as a result of their interactions with others. But, those insecurities are so frequently reinforced it becomes too much. Okay, we get is, he/she is ….insert proper characteristic here…. In a sense, there is too much detail, and as a result, the book gets a little boring.
SECOND SPOILER ALERT. Once Joy returns, there are still six or seven chapters to go. There is far too much resolution given. You know how when you reach the end of a book or movie that brings characters together after a long, suspenseful ordeal and you think, “I’d like to see more of them finally happy.” Well, it turns out you don’t really want that after all. Leave that to the imagination.
And then there’s the end–Savannah on the plane and the flashbacks to before she left home, before the beginning of the story, and what she did to her mother. This changes the focus of the whole story. Perhaps this book is not about the Delaneys as all the blurbs claim. Giving Savannah the last word changes that and forces a reevaluation as to who this book is really about. With Savannah as main character, the story turns darker, like Ian McKeown’s The Company of Strangers or Patricia Highsmith’s The Talented Mr. Ripley, and much less like a Lianne Moriarity novel. Did the PR group get it wrong, or is this a new direction for LM? Or rather is it a mash up of the two? Either way, it again feels like too much.
Did you read the book or watch the series? Leave your thoughts below, especially on whether or not you think I should watch it.